Nicole's last thoughts on Huckleberry :)


The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a piece of literature that has shaped the minds of young people in many ways. The continuation of this book should continue to be taught to high school students because it helps them develop the skills to become a better person for the world.
            The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn should be read in high schools because it shows how someone can move on, and how to become a better person. This is shown through the character Huck, and the character Jim. Huck states at the last line of the book, “But I reckon I got to light out for the Territory ahead of the rest because Aunt Sally, she’s going to adopt me and sivilize me, and I can’t stand it, I been there before” (Twain 260).  Twain showcases that Huck is “ahead” of the rest. Huck will take his adventures with him as he moves on. I believe Huck will not forget his experience with Jim. He is real. Huck realizes at this moment of the book that he has grown. Leaving for the West, Twain is showing the audience that Huck has grown into a better person. He will still make mistakes, but that is what makes Huck a real person. The high school age people will see that through Huck. They will learn that nobody is perfect; but people can strive to be a better person.
            “I would rather have my children read Uncle Tom’s Cabin” Smiley argues. She believes that The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is nothing but a waste of time.  She argues that even though Uncle Tom’s Cabin is more in-depth and contains imagination, endurance, and redemption. She feels it is more like life. I think in life we experience this ‘coming of age’  on our own time, and when were ready. That is what The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is about. Huck learns to become a better person morally.   
            It is important for young readers to relate and find curiosities in Jim. High school teachers should not only teach this book because of the main character Huck, but because of Jim as well. Jim can teach us a lot about the time period. Also Jim is able to use what he already knows to figure things out. Chadwick-Joshua explains that when she says, “it is Jim, the fully rounded character; it is not Twain who empowers Jim, for it is Jim   who empowers himself to risk sacrificing his freedom, to do what he feels is right.” We can learn from Jim when he stays with Tom Sawyer when he is hurt. What a heroic thing to do. Studying Huck Finn would teach students about the past, but it would also teach them how these two unlikely people learn values about society. Jim and Huck hold a bond that is worth looking into and figuring out who they are, and how they both grow. When Chadwick Joshua says “empowers” she means that someone who has authority to do something. Jim is giving himself “authority” to stay with Tom. This authority shows Jim’s growth in society, which can teach young students like myself to stick up to peer pressure from society. 
            Having the book read in high schools with no other changes made to it is very important. David Matthews explains, “Removing that single word from the text, while sparing those too sensitive to get past it, relieves the reader of doing any heavy lifting” I agree. I think that students will not get the benefit of the story if they replace the “n” word with slave. It does not even compare to the meaning by replacing it with slave. What would you learn?   Keeping the same word is important because Twain knew exactly what he was doing. The word holds a purpose; therefore you should leave the word in the book. Students would not learn if the book did not contain the same material as it does.



            Twain, Mark. Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. New York: Random House, 1996. Print.



Smiley. "Smiley Say It Aint So." Say It Aint So. N.p., n.d. Web.

9 comments:

  1. Nicole, I really like the way that you didn't focus to much on the n-word and instead pointed out the positives to reading Huck Finn. I agree with you that Huck Finn should be read in schools because it does teach how Huck and Jim have grown and how they have created a friendship. Those who don't think it should be read should not focus to much on the vulgar language and rather on the positives like Huck changing into a moral character. This book is such a great book to learn from because it will cause the students to discuss the issues throughout Huck Finn, and i think that is what Twain wanted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Seriously though, I adore your positive outlook on the book! It made me so happy to read something that not only promoted the book, but it did so in a very positive way with out mentioning the n-word debate and such. This Op-ed gave me a truly different look on the book proving to you that you did your job well:). No matter how important "sparing those to sensitive" subjects is, we are able to see how they are to our advantage(David Matthews). Finally where you go into detail about how the book allows us to be curious is great. All high school students need to have the urge to learn and honestly having something seen as bad in the book might intrigue them to read it...Curiosity is a gift and having something that we as growing adults can relate to is extremely useful and important for us to experience.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nicole, I really liked this! I like how you didn't focus on just the language the whole time like a lot of other Op- Eds did. A lot of other ones also just mainly focused on how buck changed and moved on, and not how Jim did. I loved how you connected the book with our 'coming of age' because I really do think it helps j\us know our own maturity better as high school students. I think Huck was running away to start fresh, not to get away from his problems so really well done! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. i really like what you had to say about Huck and Jim. i agree, and i would even say that Jim is more of an example for readers to look at, than Huck is. this is present when Jim stays to help Tom Sawyer. Tom was mean to him, and never fully respected him. But Jim stayed and helped him because of his moral being. i think that Jim is the person that we should all strive to be, and that really is what makes reading this book important.

    ReplyDelete
  5. WOW NICOLE LOOK AT ALL THAT. I can tell you worked really hard on this. :) I just wanted to say that you did a really great job not only because you are my best friend, but because you had some different points that I had not seen yet in an op-ed. I definitely think that this controversy has only focused on the "wrong" aspects such as language and racism, however you are arguing that aside from all of that, it really has a good overall message (and I agree)! I think that Huck has changed throughout the book tremendously not only on his view toward Jim, but he grew as a confident person as well. :) Great job nicole!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Nicole!!!!!! You did a awesome job!!!!! I totally agree that we can learn something from Huck and Jim and they are role models for us!!!!!! I think we can see Huck's changing character throughout the book and it is important for us to notice that! Awesome Job! :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I haven't seen it as Huck being a role model for us! That's a new way to see it, but I don't completely agree with Huck being a role model for us because he wasn't really upfront with how he respected Jim. He always out some sarcastic comment like,"he was levelheaded, well for a nigger." I understand that Huck is a child and he grew up in the south but I don't think he was an adequate role model for us just yet. Besides that, I complete agree with you! I think that this book teachers young adults how to respect one another and that the language and racism is just one of those things in life where you have to be careful with, and I believer that Twain did that excellently! Good job Nicole!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nicole great job on the revisions that you have made from the original one I read in class! I really like how you focused on the positive parts of Huck Finn rather than the controversy of the 'n-word'. I like how you made the point of high school relating to Huck as a character and that they can use him as a model to see that all people can improve their moral character! Great Job on your Op-Ed!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think that this was a really interesting perspective to look at it because you didn't focus just on the racism in the novel or on censorship. You are so right in that Huck Finn is about so much more than just the topic of racism, it encompasses a wide variety of topics that young people can experience in their lives. I also liked the fourth paragraph where you discuss that educators shouldn't just focus on Huck, because we actually can learn a lot from Jim as well and most people tend to over look him since he isn't the main character. Overall I really enjoyed your Op-Ed because you branched out and did not take the route that a lot of people (including myself) took, so it was very refreshing to read a new perspective. Great Job!

    ReplyDelete